April 30, 2007: Are English Departments Ruining the World?
I’ve been thinking a lot about something Gore Vidal said this Saturday at the Los Angeles Festival of books. He blamed English Literature Departments for destroying the novel.
He said there is only one Finnegan’s Wake. We don’t need another. But such writings are taught and favored by the Ivory Tower. Academia does not value writers with concise voices that are easy to connect with.
Consider the sharply political and brilliant books of fiction by Gore Vidal, Kurt Vonnegut, Ernest Hemingway, F. Scott Fitzgerald, Upton Sinclair, and George Orwell. Now ask: Where are the new voices of fiction? I’m not talking strictly essayists or New Journalists. I’m talking writers of fiction. Novels. Characters. Plots. Funny words strung together. Smells of biscuits and sounds of helicopters. Where are the major contemporary writers who attack and expose the problems of society with clear directives and brilliant solutions? Or have English Literature Departments been silently “corrupting” potential voices to write impenetrable worlds for arcane readerships? Watchdogs for nobody.
Part of me wants to qualify this. I love my former English Department professors. I don’t want to believe they are at fault. Also, I consider myself a writer who wishes to use both the arcane with the concise, creating surreal styles and texts. But I wonder… is academia rewarding novelists for bad writing? and in doing so, wrecking society?










